Follow @TIMEHealth
Call Paleo Chic. The eating habits of cavemen have never been more popular. But should we take menus evidence of our ancestors?
The protein-heavy, principles low carb diet of Paleo arise in restaurants as HG SPLY Co. in Dallas and Hu Kitchen in New York; Paleo inspired new exotic products such as pemmican grass-fed beef, a Native American meat paste, hit the shelves. And Miley Cyrus celebrities Kobe Bryant are followers would greedy.
While the Paleo diet has been around for years, it is just gaining some momentum Mastodon-like. But many nutrition experts are not impressed. June 3, Scientific American ran a long history that ridiculed the Paleo diet as "half-baked". The magazine suggested that the caveman was imagining- movement "a tall, thin, torn and agile 30 years "was an invention.]
Similarly, US News, in its 2014 ranking of the" Best Diets overall, "announced that the Paleo diet was basically very, tied at No. 31 with Dukan diet. "experts questioned the diet on every measure," scolded the magazine.
What beef experts, so to speak, with the regime? When it surfaces in academia in the late 1970s and the popular diet books began emerging in the 1990s, the program was promoted as a way of life and a loss method weight, cousin to Dr. Atkins and the low-carb craze.
The theory behind the diet is simple: our hunter-gatherer ancestors who survived the meat and fish that has not been saturated with antibiotics or hormones stimulating growth, as well as fresh fruits and vegetables, were on track until the agricultural revolution introduced toxins in the food chain there are about 10,000 years. So the goal is for citizens of the 21st century lean back and back and eat the way primitive people made in the Paleolithic era, there are about two million years.
But dieticians find its debt, even fussy, requirements such as bonding with very lean, meats and pure plant unrealistic. As Scientific American said, "The Paleo diet is based on more privileged than logic. Hunter-fathers in the Paleolithic hunted and gathered because they had to. people at the Paleo diet try to eat as hunter-gatherers because they want to. "Any diet that restricts certain food groups and emphasizes other are not balanced, these experts say, and there is no solid scientific evidence to prove that Paleo-eaters live longer, or are healthier than those who do not follow the diet
Marlene Zuk, an evolutionary biologist at the University of Minnesota, has a different reproach in his new book, "Paleofantasy.. Qu'est- what evolution really says about sex, food, and how we live, "she rips most contemporary notions of our Paleolithic ancestors. "I have not written a diet book," she said, "and I do not want to tell people how to eat. But I want people to understand evolution."
But the Paleo crowd passionately defends his ancestral diet. Kellyann Petrucci, nutritional clinician who is the author of three "Dummies" books on popular lifestyle Paleo ( "Living Paleo", "Paleo Cookbook" and "Paleo Workouts), it offers the benefits of part A primitive habits. "I became interested in Paleo because when I hit 40 a few years ago, I fell and burned," she said. "I was gaining weight like crazy ... my skin was lifeless, my hair started thinning and I had no energy. When I followed the Paleo model, it was clear to me that something was going on a deep cellular level. Not only have I myself back, but a healthier and more dynamic version. "
Perhaps the most outspoken defender of Paleodom Chris Kresser, whose new book" Your code Paleo Personal "(read an excerpt here) provides a detailed roadmap for the lifestyle. Kresser who practices integrative and functional medicine in Berkeley, Cal., Assigns regime with restoring his own health after years of painful digestive disease. "Today, I am blessed with good health, a loving family and a thriving practice, "he said.
Kresser argues that in fact science supports Paleo principles. "There is a broad consensus among scientists that our Paleolithic ancestors consumed mainly meat, fish, vegetables, fruits, nuts, seeds and starchy tubers "He rejects the claim that the diet is too labor-intensive for the average person, or is difficult to find the ingredients of these previous regimes, citing a plethora of restaurants and new convenience foods such as gluten / sugar / soy-free beef jerky, kale chips and grain gluten-free crackers and deserts.
Over the past three years, he said he has treated 900 people in his office in Berkeley, California. "My practice has been closed to new patients for most of the past two years," he says, "because there is a high demand for clinicians who embrace Paleo in their work." Kresser said that the plan is booming in popularity because "Many people experience a profound change in their health after switching to Paleo and they are happy to share with others. This created one base, the movement of people wanting to get the word powerful word-of-mouth. "
This word is not enough, however. New York City nutritionist Jennifer Andrus sees wise nutritional principles in food, such as meats and lean fish, fruits and vegetables, but said that it is not necessary to go to extremes of Paleo crowd. "it eliminates dairy products, legumes and other foods that can be part of healthy diet." Although she shares the concerns of the people about Paleo food and modern convenience candy, she is also concerned about our current gluttony "I think that processed foods deserves criticism, but probably not because we have not evolved. most likely because we eat too much of it and most of it is empty nutritionally. "
Andrus suggests a common sense strategy, one that Kresser said in his book, he can take out." Some people like to comply with the 80/20 rule; if 80% of your diet is perfect, there is some leeway for the rest, "she said. After all," There is plenty of space between Paleo and a shit eating Pop-Tarts and McDonald . "
0 Komentar